In the sultry haze of a Delray Beach evening, where palm fronds rustle like secrets in the Atlantic breeze, Emily stepped into The Blue Anchor Pub on East Atlantic Avenue. It was her first visit to this slice of old London transplanted to Florida’s sun-kissed shore—a 19th-century tavern, born in the fog-shrouded streets of 1840s England during the shadow of Jack the Ripper, only to be lovingly disassembled, shipped across the ocean in 1996, and rebuilt into the bones of a 1946 structure. The air inside hummed with the clink of imperial pints and the sizzle of fish and chips, but Emily, a skeptical history buff chasing tales for her travel blog, had come for more than bangers and mash. She’d heard the whispers: the pub wasn’t just historic; it was haunted. And not by any run-of-the-mill specter, but by Bertha Starkey, the betrayed bride whose fury had crossed the Atlantic like an uninvited guest.
The wooden beams overhead, scarred by two centuries of spilled ale and sharper sorrows, creaked as if sighing under an invisible weight. Emily settled at the scarred oak bar, ordering a frothy Guinness while eavesdropping on locals swapping yarns. “Bertha was a firecracker,” murmured old-timer Jack, nursing his pint with a wink. “Lived upstairs in the original London spot with her sailor husband, gone months at sea. One stormy night in the 1800s, he docks early, catches her in a lover’s embrace—right here where you’re sittin’—and in a jealous rage, he ends ’em both with a blade. No trial, no mercy. Her spirit? Stuck, wailin’ for justice that never came.” Emily chuckled, chalking it up to pub folklore, until the clock struck 10 p.m.—the witching hour of Bertha’s demise. A chill slithered down her spine, unnatural in the humid Florida night, as candles on the walls flickered to life on their own, casting elongated shadows that danced like frantic lovers. Glasses rattled along the shelves, not from the rowdy crowd of soccer fans cheering a Premier League match on the telly, but from an unseen hand shoving them aside in petty rage.
As the evening deepened, the pranks escalated into something profoundly eerie. A barmaid shrieked as pots clanged in the kitchen like a poltergeist tantrum, lids flying off and crashing to the floor. “Bertha’s at it again,” the staff laughed nervously, but Emily’s eyes widened when a spectral figure materialized in the foggy mirror behind the bar—a pale woman in a tattered Victorian gown, her dark curls disheveled, eyes hollow with betrayal. Bertha Starkey, they called her, forever 28, her translucent form gliding through patrons oblivious to her touch. Emily froze as icy fingers brushed her shoulder, accompanied by a mournful wail that drowned out the pub’s raucous laughter: a lament for stolen passion, for a life cut short in the throes of forbidden desire. Heart pounding, Emily bolted for the door, but not before glimpsing Bertha’s ghost pause at a table of young lovers, her ethereal gaze softening with envy before dissolving into mist.
The next morning, nursing a hangover laced with disbelief, Emily pored over grainy clips from Ghost Hunters International and America’s Most Haunted Pubs, shows that had stormed The Blue Anchor’s creaky floors years ago, capturing EVPs of Bertha’s sobs and orbs of light darting like fireflies in the gloom. Owners Mark and Peggy Snyder, who took the reins in 2017, had their own tales: breaker switches flipping off during closing, leaving the pub in pitch black; footsteps padding upstairs in empty rooms; and once, during a cleaning frenzy, every light blazing to life as if Bertha demanded her spotlight. Yet, for all her wrath, Bertha seemed less vengeful poltergeist and more tragic guardian—flicking off fuses to shoo away drunks after last call, or dimming bulbs to foster quiet confessions over late-night pints. Emily returned that very night, pint in hand, toasting to the ghost who’d turned a simple pub into a portal between worlds. In Delray Beach, where the sun bleaches secrets from the sand, The Blue Anchor endures as Bertha’s eternal tavern: a place where history pours as freely as the beer, and the dead raise a glass to remind the living that some loves, like fine ale, linger forever.
The Blue Anchor Pub
804 E Atlantic Ave
Delray Beach, FL 33483
Website: theblueanchorpub.com
Top 10 Haunted Bars and Taverns in America